Achievement •

A Community-Cultural Approach to Combat the K–12 Reading Crisis

LinkedIn Card
BY Matthew Barton

IN THIS ARTICLE

SHARE THIS STORY:

A reading crisis may sound like a losing battle, but there is a light at the end of the tunnel. Reading problems tend to originate in the household before students ever set foot in a classroom. Nipping this issue in the bud also starts in the home but requires a whole-community approach that acts as an umbrella, fostering a positive culture of reading for students from pre-K through high school.

Pre-K: The effects of technology and attention

There are several issues impacting reading scores across the nation, starting around the pre-K level. Post-pandemic, parents are reading to pre-K children less often and for less time. Though parents likely have good intentions, they may overestimate time spent reading to kids. According to the Matthew Effect (ironic that I’m citing it, I know), the more time children spend reading, or exposed to reading, the better they become at it. Unfortunately, this effect also works in reverse in households that don’t prioritize reading.

Many teachers, pre-K through high school, also report increased attention issues, believing technology to be the underlying culprit. Though technology has only been correlated with slight changes in attention ability, the desire to pay attention is heavily impacted. Consciously or unconsciously, students from pre-K to grade 12 compare everything with the highly stimulating content they could otherwise be viewing on their personal devices. The problem starts at home: 40% of 2-year-olds have their own tablet. Paired with common symptoms of drug withdrawals, children are suffering from technological addiction, often beginning this cycle of emotional dependency before kindergarten.

Pre-K administrators and district leaders in general can help to solve these issues by influencing at-home culture. Some examples include:

  • Aiming for parents to read 1,000 books with their kids by kindergarten to help set future students up for maximum success. This can be encouraged using a rewards program if the benefits alone aren’t enough for some families.
  • Encouraging minimal and monitored use of technology in schools and homes.

Arrival at school: Creating the culture

As students enter elementary classrooms, educators must continue to find new ways to engage students, which may feel like an immense task. Because engaging with increasingly long texts for greater lengths of time is directly associated with better attention, district leaders and educators have an opportunity to carefully curate their community’s culture, spreading the message that reading is not just interesting, but an intrinsic means for joy.

When students are given the opportunity to find books they might enjoy at their reading level, they can become excited about it. This is a critical moment where teachers can foster a student’s love of reading as more than a mere homework assignment. There are five proven methods to get kids interested and excited about reading:

Environmental Design

Teachers keeping a variety of books in a classroom library, rather than solely relying on the school library, report students’ increased curiosity and engagement with the books surrounding them. In simpler terms: build it and they will come.

Zone of Proximal Development

For a book to be the right fit for a student, especially younger readers developing their skills, it must fit within their Zone of Proximal development (ZPD). The text cannot be easy, but must also not be so difficult that the student is lost or overwhelmed even with help from an instructor. The sweet spot is when just enough assistance is needed that the student can experience new things and improve their abilities.

Human Interest

It has long been theorized that many reading scores appear lower than students’ actual ability simply because the prompts and excerpts aren’t interesting. People perform better when they care about what they are doing.

School librarians are uniquely equipped to help pair students with enjoyable books, but classroom teachers can also help with this. Many teachers allow for a “speed dating” process for students to spend time flipping through books to determine what they might find intriguing. For example, a speed dating process for fiction might allow a young student to find a graphic novel like Dog Man more interesting than a Junie B. Jones book. This can also be done with curriculum book sets for older students, while still teaching similar themes and nuances.

Another more recent example of engaging readers is to use AI to create texts, uniquely designed to fit each student’s ZPD and interests. The stories can incorporate characters or themes that students enjoy, like Minecraft, Pokémon, Disney Princesses, etc., without breaking the bank to gather real branded books for every reading level. Personalized AI texts require heavy review by instructors, however, to ensure the texts are well written and actually within the student’s ZPD.

Reading as a Social Activity

Once upon a time, Pokémon videogames roared into popularity because they were used as a social tool. Kids had to meet up on the playground and trade Pokémon with each other that were locked behind a specific version of the game, leading to the cultural movement in the 90’s deemed “Poké-mania.” The same pattern can be found with reading.

When a group of students share a story they are interested in, they can engage with the material in those groups, discussing character arcs, plotlines, themes, and more. Students increasingly question why they must learn what they are learning and whether it will matter in the future. By using reading as a social activity, students will receive and comprehend both immediate and long-term benefits in the form of social connection with peers and increased literacy over time.

The Library’s Role

Reading rewards programs like Pizza Hut’s “Book It!” offer external awards for reading, however this might give the subconscious sub-text to children that reading is something they must be coaxed into doing, not an intrinsic reward within itself. Thus, allowing time for librarians to speak with children to learn about their values and interests will help the librarian point young readers in the direction of well-liked series or unique gems that align best with the student. For example, if kids like scary books but are sick of the same several Goosebumps entries in the library, a librarian might know to point them towards another R.L. Stine classic series like Fear Street or similar books like Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark. By acting as “salesmen,” librarians can work with teachers to ensure reading is an engaging and fun activity for all.

Extend an Arm to Older Students

A staggering number of older K-12 students are currently struggling with reading and comprehension. Though 20% of students experience some form of dyslexia, 44% of students grades 3-8 report struggling to understand in-class content, indicating that there is a breakdown of learning on top of natural ability. Many students that were socially promoted throughout their elementary years still lack foundational reading skills. This can, however, be remedied.

Teaching older students to read effectively is vastly different from younger students. Older students may try to hide their deficits out of embarrassment and must be convinced that investing their time to improve reading at an older age will be worthwhile. This is a difficult task in and of itself, without even considering the hill educators must climb to not infantilize or discourage older struggling readers by using easier kids’ books to teach the missed skills. Thus, creating a safe space for older students with age-appropriate materials is mandatory for them to feel comfortable seeking assistance.

Some schools have allowed teachers to start classes targeting underdeveloped areas of reading for older kids, specifically decoding, breaking larger words into smaller chunks, and gaining a deeper understanding of suffixes and prefixes. A mix of teachers reading to the class as students follow along in their own books, students reading aloud, and reading-to-self allows classes to move at their own pace, ensuring learning for all. Learning to decode and break up larger words sets the stage for reading more demanding material, such as STEM textbooks.

Because older students who have been enrolled in literacy classes have seen eight times as much reading growth as those who have not, the classes may be the third key in curbing the literacy crisis, lowering attention-related behavioral issues, and swaying avoidant readers into those that read for fun and feel comfortable doing so. Much of the cultural approach to reading encouragement depends on beginning early, but leaders can use different tactics to reach older students with the message that valuable reading skills can be developed, there is still time to learn.

When educators create a culture of safety, vulnerability, and understanding, reading culture can shift from fear and avoidance to interest and joy.


WHAT'S NEXT FOR YOUR EDTECH?
The right combo of tools & support retains staff and serves students better.
We'd love to help. Visit skyward.com/get-started to learn more.


SHARE THIS STORY:
ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Model.Author Matthew Barton
Edtech Thought Leader


READ MORE FROM ADVANCING K12

Security

This site uses cookies to improve your browsing experience and to help us understand how you use our site. To learn more about how we use this data, read our privacy policy. By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our cookie policy.